Pain is only a problem to those who believe
that pain is an objectively bad thing, and that an alternative is both
available and better. Without suggesting
that theodicy is simple, I would contend that those who cling to some sort of naturalistic
beliefs on the pretext that religion can’t answer the problem of pain (or evil, for that matter)
are being rather disingenuous. Consistent with that view, the response to the question of the problem of pain should simply be “What’s
the problem?”
Love it...
ReplyDeleteYou and the Marquis, De Sade that is,...you guys would get on splendidly.
On a serious note, I do think the question you raise is worthwhile.
Yeah, me and the Marquis are like peas in a pod, alright :D I guess this was kind of an off-the-wall post, but I was reading some non-religious folks criticizing Christianity over the age old issue of the problem of pain, and it seems to me the very fact that the question exists presupposes a hope and longing for a better, redeemed state that atheists aren't entitled to presume. I guess posting my silly thoughts in my little online journal doesn't really do much to address that, though.
ReplyDelete